Casey #2 - New York City

Coverboy 07/10/2004, 09/28/2004

Review #10, 06/23/2006

Name: Casey:
Location: Tampa Bay
Email: nycmuscleman1@aol.com
Phone: 917-282-7503
Website: www.hometown.aol.com/nycmuscleman1

Ethnicity: Caucasian Age: 30''s
Height: 6''1" (185 cm) Weight: 240-250 lbs (109-113 kg) Build: Muscled
Eyes: Green Hair: Short Brown
Body Hair: Smooth Facial Hair: Shaved
Cock: Unknown 7-8" (18-20 cm) Thick

Orientation: Bi
Roles: Companion Escort Modeling Worship
Calls: In/Out
Smoking: No Drinking: No
Rates for time only(US $): 1st=250 Overnight=1200

Date: 06/2006 Type: Overnight Rate: 1200
Rating: Recommended Hire Again? Yes
Where Found? Hooboys M4M
Reviewed Before? Yes Match Description? Yes Lived up? Yes

Experience: Casey and I have met before in New York when we did a role play and he did a great job. I decided to approach him about visiting me in North Carolina for some additional role plays. Casey was prompt and courteous with his responses and setting up a date was no problem at all.

He looks even better than the first time we met and we did several role plays and he was fantastic in every single one of them.

Casey is the best and I highly recommend him.

Handle: wichita672122003
Submissions: Second Review
Previous Reviews: Casey - #2

You: Overweight GWM in early 40s

Review #9, 04/06/2006

Name: Casey:
Location: Tampa Bay
Email: nycmuscleman1@aol.com
Phone: 917-282-7503
Website: www.hometown.aol.com/nycmuscleman1

Ethnicity: Caucasian Age: 30''s
Height: 6''1" (185 cm) Weight: 240-250 lbs (109-113 kg) Build: Muscled
Eyes: Green/Hazel Hair: Average Brown/Black
Body Hair: Smooth Facial Hair: Smooth
Cock: Unknown 7-8" (18-20 cm) Average

Orientation: Bi Kissing: Yes Anal: No Oral: Gets Kink: Dominant
Roles: Escort Modeling Worship Travel
Calls: In/Out
Smoking: No Drinking: Tolerant
Rates for time only(US $): 1st=250

Date: 03/2006 Type: 1 Hour Rate: 250
Rating: Satisfactory Hire Again? Yes
Where Found? Other website Which: rentboy

Reviewed Before? Yes Match Description? Yes Lived up? Yes

Experience: After seeing Casey at the website, I was impressed with his physique and wanted to experience a large bodybuilder. He came through, despite some nerves on my part, in spades. This is a gentle man and a gentleman, but underneath that exterior there is a simmering man who will take charge and take control. He put at ease with his generous nature as we talked about our lives and our interests. We discussed baseball, an injury he had sustained, and real estate demonstrating his ability to talk about anything with ease. Once the action got started, on his invitation to my bedroom, he was outstanding. His muscles pleased and thrilled me. Casey showed me how a man with muscle can caress, kiss, and yet control. Our session was gentle and calm, but our next encounter will no doubt be more active and more edgy. Casey helped me plan and define what my likes and dislikes are, and also directed me. He helped push the edge of my envelope and will be someone I spend ti
me with in the future. He splits time between New York and Florida, and is the gold standard for me now. The muscle will keep me coming back, the man will fill that time with untold pleasure.

Handle: donpat
Submissions: Fourth Review
Previous Reviews: Jay (Tampa), Todd (Phoenix), David (Seattle)

You: late 40''s / early 50''s, professional of average build and limited experience (but gaining it), interested in muscle first and expanding and experimenting my boundaries. Discretion is a priority. I take advantage of the opportunity to act on urges and desires.

Review #8, 02/15/2006

Name: CASEY 2:
Location: NEW YORK
Email: nycmuscleman1@aol.com
Phone: 917-282-7503
Website: www.hometown.aol.com/nycmuscleman1

Ethnicity: Caucasian Age: 20's
Height: 6'1" (185 cm) Weight: 230-240 lbs (104-109 kg) Eyes: Green/Hazel Hair: Average Brown/Black
Body Hair: Smooth Facial Hair: Smooth
Cock: Cut 7-8" (18-20 cm) Average

Orientation: Straight Kissing: Yes Oral: Gets Kink: Dominate
Roles: Escort Worship Travel
Calls: In/Out

Rates for time only(US $): 1st=250.

Date: 01/2006 Type: 1 Hour Rate: 250.0
Rating: Recommended Hire Again? Yes
Where Found? Other website Which: rentboy.com

Reviewed Before? Yes Match Description? Yes Lived up? Yes

Experience: I saw Casey's ad on RentBoy and emailed him for an appointment while he was in NYC. He wrote back and then called me to set every thing up. We talked about what he would do & the cost. There is no deceitfulness here, he is honest and up front. We meet outside the hotel where he was as sweet as could be, but when he got in the room he became a leathermaster par excellante He dressed in his leather and talk to me like a slave. I loved it. He talked dirty to me and we discussed taking a blond slaveboy,bounding him & flogging him until he cries. He promised to surprise me with this scene the next time in his New York apt. This Man has a diabolical imagination that can really excite you.I will be seeing him again Thanks Casey!

Handle: JERSEY AL
Submissions: Third Review
Previous Reviews: TREY REXX, LEO BRAUM, NYC
KEVIN THOMAS NYC

You: 60 Year old teddy bear type that enjoys being with muscle masters for worship and service.

Review #7, 08/24/2005

Name: Casey:
Location: New York City
Email: nycmuscleman1@aol.com
Phone: 917-282-7503
Website: http://hometown.aol.com/nycmuscleman1

Ethnicity: Caucasian Age: 20's
Height: 6'1" (185 cm) Weight: 230-240 lbs (104-109 kg) Build: Muscled
Eyes: Green/Hazel Hair: Short Brown
Body Hair: Shaved Facial Hair: Shaved
Cock: Cut 7-8" (18-20 cm) Unknown

Orientation: Bi Kissing: Yes Masturbation: Both Anal: No Oral: Gets
Roles: Escort Worship
Smoking: No Drinking: No
Rates for time only(US $): 1st=250

Date: 07/05 Type: 1 Hour Rate: 250
Rating: Recommended Hire Again? Yes
Where Found? Hooboys M4M Which: Nextboys.com

Reviewed Before? Yes Match Description? Yes Lived up? Yes

Experience:
What an incredible guy. He is extremely handsome although in a different way from the handsome pic posted on this site and others. I asked for role play and he delivered. He was so attractive, so attentive to me. I'll never forget how incredible the view was with him face down on my bed, massive legs spread.... We talked for probably an additional hour and he seemed ready to stay as long as I could stay awake. Felt like we were friends by the time he left. I would highly recommend this young man and will definitely hire him again myself.

Handle: Muscle Lover
Submissions: First Review

You:
Late 30s, average bod, not bad looking.

Review #6, 08/01/2005

Name: Casey#2:
Location: New York City
Email: nycmuscleman1@aol.com
Phone: 917-282-7503
Website: http://hometown.aol.com/nycmuscleman1

Ethnicity: Caucasian Age: 20's
Height: 6'1" (185 cm) Weight: 230-240 lbs (104-109 kg) Build: Muscled
Eyes: Green Hair: Average Brown
Body Hair: Smooth Facial Hair: Smooth
Cock: Unknown 7-8" (18-20 cm) Average

Orientation: Bi Kissing: Yes Masturbation: Gives
Roles: Escort Massage Modeling Worship
Calls: In/Out
Smoking: No
Rates for time only(US $): 1st=250

Date: 07/2005 Type: 1 Hour Rate: $250
Rating: Recommended Hire Again? Yes
Where Found? Other website Which: MuscleServiceLogbook

Reviewed Before? Yes Match Description? Yes Lived up? Yes

Experience:
I'm not a kink kind of guy - I understand Casey has a clientele who admire a player on the wild side - but I do know a hot looking man with a great personality when I meet one. Casey fills that bill oh so well!

He's also beautifully muscled and smooth, with perhaps the best-looking ass in the business. I had a great time playing with him; he knows how to use his sexy mouth and those kissable full lips; he's extremely interactive; and I hope he doesn't mind me saying - kink hirers cover your eyes - he's as cuddly as a hairless teddy bear.

Included in the great "companionship" were conversations about ourselves, our pasts, our lives now and what we're hoping for. I couldn't have had a better time.

Gentlemen: he's awfully good at what he does. Anyone who's looking for more than a quick romp under the sheets will not be disappointed.

And oh that sweet, sweet ass!

Handle: JimB
Submissions: 5 or more Reviews
Previous Reviews:
I can only locate three reviews still on the website: Jay-NYC reviewed 11/15/05, Kevin Thomas - Miami reviewed 6/1/02, and Sebastian - Fort Lauderdale reviewed 2/19/03.

You:
White guy, workout regularly, 40's, who likes men of all sizes and colors. The only requirement being they tote around a big beautiful ass that they love to share with others. Not necessarily for bottoming (that didn't come up in my session with Casey), but an ass that enjoys attention is manditory.

Review #5, 03/31/2005

Name: Casey:
Location: New York City
Email: nycmuscleman1@aol.com
Phone: 917-282-7503
Website: Casey's Web Site

Ethnicity: Caucasian Age: 20's
Height: 6'1" (185 cm) Weight: 240-250 lbs (109-113 kg) Build: Muscled
Eyes: Green Hair: Short Brown
Body Hair: Smooth Facial Hair: Shaved
Cock: Unknown 7-8" (18-20 cm) Thick

Orientation: Bi
Roles: Companion Escort Modeling
Calls: In/Out
Smoking: No
Rates for time only(US $): 1st=250

Date: 03/2005 Type: 1 Hour Rate: 250
Rating: Recommended Hire Again? Yes
Where Found? Hooboys M4M
Reviewed Before? Yes Match Description? Yes Lived up? Yes

Experience:
I do not know where to start about Casey. All I can say is WOW!!!. Casey is all he advertises and more. He appears to be in his late 20s to early 30s. He has an unbelievable body and is also handsome.

When he walked into my hotel room, I could not believe my eyes. He is not a clock watcher and we talked prior to starting the role play. During the role play, he did exactly what I asked and did it perfectly. When we were through, we talked some more before he left.

I would highly recommend Casey and believe me, he is worth the wait!!!!

Handle: wichita672122003
Submissions: First Review
Previous Reviews: Casey#2-New York

You:

Older Reviews

Due to circumstances beyond our control, reviews that predate March, 2005 have to be reloaded from the database, and reprocessed before being put back on the site. We apologize for the inconvenience, and we are working to get these reviews back online as quickly as possible.